Alistair Johnston

Recent reports from August to October 2026 extensively covered Everton's pursuit. Celtic's asking price was consistently reported at £15 million (approx. €18 million), with some reports mentioning figures 'upwards of £15m' and one as high as £20 million (approx. €24 million). Everton's offers were reportedly around £12 million (approx. €14 million), with a potential deal structure rising to £15 million with add-ons. One report in August 2026 suggested Celtic would be willing to sell for approximately £14 million (approx. €16.5 million). Earlier, in May 2026, his Transfermarkt value was noted as €8 million. His most recent completed transfer was from CF Montréal to Celtic in January 2023 for a fee of €3.5 million.

Our valuation is driven by the extensive and consistent reporting during the summer 2026 transfer window regarding Everton's strong interest in Alistair Johnston. The range is anchored by Everton's reported offers around €14 million (£12m) and Celtic's firm asking price of approximately €18 million (£15m). Celtic's strong negotiating position, with the player contracted until 2029, supports a final fee closer to their valuation, leading to our estimate. The player's subsequent injury halted the transfer but the underlying valuation from the negotiations remains the strongest evidence.