During the summer of 2023, Nick Olij was in advanced discussions with Ajax, competing with Diant Ramaj for a position. Ajax eventually selected Ramaj, leading to disappointment for Olij. The negotiations had progressed to the point where the choice was between Olij and Ramaj, as Olij confirmed on the Ziggo Sport show, Rondo. Despite this setback, Olij maintained a pragmatic view, acknowledging that life continues and his ambition is to reach the highest level possible in football. After Ajax's decision, Olij garnered interest from PSV and Feyenoord the following summer, though no transfer occurred. The Sparta goalkeeper remains focused on future opportunities, determined to demonstrate his skills and explore potential transfers in the upcoming summer.