James Garner

In November 2025, reports cited a Transfermarkt market value of €22.00m. In September and October 2025, his Transfermarkt value was reported at €18.00m. Multiple reports from late 2025 describe a potential January transfer as being for a 'low fee' or 'nominal fee' due to his contract situation. His last completed transfer was from Manchester United to Everton in September 2022 for a reported €10.4M.

Our valuation for James Garner is primarily driven by his expiring contract situation, which reports suggest could lead to a 'low fee' or 'nominal fee' in a January transfer. This significantly discounts his estimated market value of €18-22 million. However, strong interest from multiple Premier League clubs, including Manchester United and Newcastle, combined with Everton's desire to keep him, creates upward pressure on any potential fee, preventing a bottom-dollar sale. The range reflects a compromise between these competing factors, sitting above his last transfer fee of €10.4 million from 2022.